Despite the hooplah of Paris and Marakkesh, a new article by Jeremy Brecher argues that climate protection will never be accomplished by existing government and institutional actors. “Climate Emergency: Global Insurgency: There is no choice but to escalate today’s campaigns against global fossil fuel infrastructure” appeared in Common Dreams on October 14 , and while the author commends the protests against the Dakota Access Pipeline, (mirrored in Canada by protests against the Kinder Morgan Pipeline) he quotes Bill McKibben that “Fighting one pipeline at a time, the industry will eventually prevail.” Brecher advocates instead what he calls a “global nonviolent constitutional insurgency”. “A non-violent insurgency, like an armed insurgency, refuses to accept the limits on its action imposed by the powers that be. Unlike an armed insurgency, it eschews violence and instead expresses power by mobilizing people for mass nonviolent direct action….It is not formally a revolutionary movement because it does not challenge the legitimacy of the fundamental law; rather, it asserts that current officials are in violation of the very laws that they themselves claim provide the justification for their authority. Although the established courts may condemn and punish them, constitutional insurgents view their “civil disobedience” as actually obedience to law, even a form of law enforcement.”
Recalling the great civil disobedience campaigns of Gandhi, the American civil rights movement, and Polish Solidarity movement , Brecher points to the current “Break Free From Fossil Fuels” global campaign, begun after the Paris Agreement in 2015, as an encouraging start to the climate insurgency he advocates. The U.S. organizers of Break Free From Fossil Fuels issued a “Public Trust Proclamation” which summarizes the principles. The legal actions inspired by the Urgenda case and Our Children’s Trust in the U.S. share many of the same values, but apply them in the courts. Brecher links these two movements in an earlier article, “A new wave of climate insurgents defines itself as law-enforcers“. Brecher’s 2014 book, Climate Insurgency: A Strategy for Survival has been updated and reissued as a free ebook , to make it as widely available as possible to those who want to understand and help halt climate change.
Note: In Canada, the May 2016 Break Free protests were focused on the Kinder Morgan pipeline (photos still available here ). Protests are continuing – including sit-ins in the offices of government ministers in November, as even the federal government’s Ministerial Panel Report , released on November 3, raises questions about how the pipeline fits with the government’s commitments on climate change, First Nations reconciliation, and social license for fossil fuel projects. According to Environmental Defence, rejecting Kinder Morgan and restarting the review process after reforming the National Energy Board is the only viable option for the federal government. The government’s decision is due December 19, and is seen as a defining moment for the Trudeau government to demonstrate a clear commitment to its climate goals, rather than a compromise with energy/economics.