Updated September 11:
On September 11, CBC News broke the news that “Greenpeace suing Ontario government over cancellation of cap-and-trade program” . The lawsuit was filed in Ontario Superior Court by EcoJustice and the University of Ottawa’s Ecojustice Environmental Law Clinic. It asks the Court to quash the legislation, on the grounds that the Conservative government “unlawfully failed” to hold public consultations before cancelling the program, as required by Ontario’s Environmental Bill of Rights. An expedited hearing on the matter has been granted and scheduled for September 21. The EcoJustice press release of September 11 is here .
At issue is Bill 4, The Cap and Trade Cancellation Act, 2018 , introduced in July to honour a campaign pledge to repeal Ontario’s cap and trade program, authorized through the Climate Change Mitigation and Low-carbon Economy Act, 2016 of the previous Wynne government. Yet as the National Observer reported on August 15, “Ontario legislature adjourns without adopting Ford government bill to cancel cap and trade” . The article also compiles expert opinion and reaction to the move, and notes that the government will be expected to propose new greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets when the Ontario legislature returns for its fall sitting on Sept. 24.
In “Ford government does U-turn, expands electric vehicle rebates for Tesla buyers” (Aug. 31), CBC reports on another Court case involving the rookie Ford government. The Court ruled against the government and in favour of Tesla, which had claimed that it had been discriminated against when the government discontinued electric and hybrid vehicle sales incentives. The CBC quotes Sara Singh, an Ontario NDP MP, who stated in August: “This is likely only the first of many decisions against the Ford government’s decision to rip up hundreds of cap-and-trade and green energy contracts.” The Huffington Post compiled a list the legal actions against the government, on a variety of fronts, on Sept. 5.
Others who have weighed in on Ford’s climate and energy policies: Climate Action Network, along with 37 signatories, sent an Open Letter to Premier Ford on August 8. It documents the heat and fire emergencies throughout the province in the summer of 2018, and calls for a public commitment, along with a detailed plan, to achieve Ontario’s existing legislated emissions reduction goals. Environmental Defence maintains an online petition calling for similar action.
Regarding Ford’s cuts to renewable energy programs: A widely-cited article appeared in Forbes magazine: “Ontario’s Economic Investment Outlook Dims With New Government Energy Actions” (Aug. 13) (and was re-posted by the Pembina Institute ) stating: “In one fell swoop Ontario’s government has dramatically slashed a source of funding for clean transportation infrastructure to help consumers lower travel costs, erased hundreds of clean energy projects to help consumers reduce electricity costs, dimmed the prospects for jobs and economic growth from clean tech industries, and took a major step backwards in making the province an attractive climate for business and investment today – and into the future.”