The Alberta Federation of Labour has launched a campaign “by and for Alberta’s workers” in advance of the provincial election in Spring 2019. The Next Alberta Campaign website compares the party platforms of the NDP and the United Conservative Party (UCP) , characterized as “pragmatists” and “dinosaurs” – with a clear preference for the pragmatist NDP platform. In a March 13 press release, the AFL also released their own 12 Point Plan with this introduction by Gil McGowan, AFL President : “The old policy prescriptions of corporate tax cuts and deregulation .. are particularly ill-suited to the challenges we face today. And simply waiting for the next boom, as Alberta governments have done for decades, is not an option because it probably won’t happen. Like it or not, our future is going to be defined by change. So, the priority needs to be getting our people and our economy ready for that change, instead of sticking our heads in the sand.”
What exactly does the AFL propose? Their 12 Point Plan includes initiatives around five themes: Support Alberta’s oil & gas industry; Diversify the economy; Invest in Infrastructure; Invest in people (by investing in public services, including expanding medicare, child care and free tuition, and expanding pension plans); and Protect Workers’ Rights. With a very pragmatic orientation, the document has no mention of “Just Transition” or coal phase-out, and emissions reduction is proposed in these terms: “Reduce carbon emissions, as much as possible, from each barrel of oil produced in Alberta so, we can continue to access markets with increasingly stringent emission standards.”
On the issue of the oil and gas industry, the Plan states:
We need to build new pipelines to access markets other than the U.S.
We need to incentivize and support oil and gas companies in their efforts to reduce emissions so we can continue to access markets with increasingly stringent environmental standards.
Our goal should be to make sure that Alberta is last heavy oil producer standing in an increasingly carbon constrained world.
On the issue of Infrastructure, the 12-Point Plan calls for:
procurement policies need to be revamped, for example, to use Community Benefit Agreements which emphasize the public interest by awarding contracts to companies that hire local, buy local and achieve thresholds related to environmental, social, and economic factors.
companies and contractors working on public infrastructure projects need to comply with labour standards, provide fair pay, and provide training for Albertans.
Research into communicating energy policies: The Alberta Narrative Project released a report, Communicating Climate Change and Energy in Alberta in February, documenting Albertan’s voices on issues of climate change, oil sands, politics, and more. Some highlights are cited in “Lessons in talking climate with Albertan Oil Workers” (Feb. 21), including:
“In Alberta, recognising the role that oil and gas has played in securing local livelihoods proved crucial. Most environmentalists would balk at a narrative of ‘gratitude’ towards oil, but co-producing an equitable path out of fossil fuel dependency means making oil sands workers feel valued, not attacked. Empathic language that acknowledges oil’s place in local history could therefore be the key to cultivating support for decarbonisation.
…..This project was also one of the first to test language specifically on energy transitions. While participants were generally receptive to the concept, the word ‘just’, with its social justice connotations, proved to be anything but politically neutral. In an environment where attitudes towards climate are bound to political identities, many interviewees showed a reluctance to the idea of government handouts, even where an unjust transition would likely put them out of a job. Rather, the report recommends a narrative of ‘diversification’ rather than ‘transition’, stressing positive future opportunities instead of moving away from a negative past.”
The Alberta Narratives Project is part of the global Climate Outreach Initiative, whose goal is to understand and train communicators to deliver effective communications which lead to cooperative approaches. The Alberta Narratives Project, with lead partners The Pembina Institute and Alberta Ecotrust, coordinated 75 community organizations to host 55 facilitated “Narrative Workshops” around the province, engaging an unusually broad spectrum of people: farmers, oil sands workers, energy leaders, business leaders, youth, environmentalists, New Canadians and others.
Pembina Institute communications seem to reflect the goal of an inclusive, constructive tone. For example, their pre-election report, Energy Policy Leadership in Alberta , released on March 8, makes recommendations regarding renewable energy, energy efficiency, coal phase-out, methane regulation, and “legislating an emissions reduction target for Alberta that is consistent with ensuring Canada meets its international obligations under the Paris climate agreement.” Also, Pricing Carbon Pollution in Alberta (March 8), which places carbon pricing in the history of the province since 2007, stresses the benefits, and makes recommendations relevant to the current political debate.